Ranting, redux.
Apr. 24th, 2010 07:14 pmAfter taking a couple of days to think it over, I've realized my anger over the Broccoli Test isn't from the idea of measuring how well a pairing can communicate without words - it's the application of that measurement. The Broccoli Test is something that's applied to a situation where nonverbal communication flat-out isn't needed, so a lot of my confusion and frustration came from trying to understand that. If one member of a couple can't think to walk over to the other and ask them about the broccoli, that's actually kind of pathetic. If the test applied to a situation where verbal communication can't be employed, like during a long sit-down dinner with family members or being held hostage at gunpoint, that'd make more sense. But if someone can't think to walk over and put the broccoli in the shopping basket on their own, well, I've got no sympathy.
Communicating "I love you and all that you are but if your mother doesn't stop talking about her cyst I'm going to walk outside and throw myself in front of a bus" or "I love you and you need to trust me and throw yourself out the window, grab onto the fire escape, and shimmy down the drainpipe and call the cops while I make a distraction for you" through eye contact and subtle facial expressions is much more understandable. Heck, look at the example in this little sketch - communicating that look takes genuine skill.
I guess changing the phrase to "The Reference Desk Test" wouldn't go over so well.
Communicating "I love you and all that you are but if your mother doesn't stop talking about her cyst I'm going to walk outside and throw myself in front of a bus" or "I love you and you need to trust me and throw yourself out the window, grab onto the fire escape, and shimmy down the drainpipe and call the cops while I make a distraction for you" through eye contact and subtle facial expressions is much more understandable. Heck, look at the example in this little sketch - communicating that look takes genuine skill.
I guess changing the phrase to "The Reference Desk Test" wouldn't go over so well.