hannah: (Luke Skywalker - elefwin)
hannah ([personal profile] hannah) wrote2019-01-05 10:01 pm

Hear the words.

Day 3

In your own space, share a favorite piece of original canon (a TV episode, a song, a favorite interview, a book, a scene from a movie, etc) and explain why you love it so much. Leave a comment in this post saying you did it. Include a link to your post if you feel comfortable doing so.


I've joked there are two scenarios where it's acceptable to begin reading the Discworld series with The Color of Magic: it's 1983 and it's the most recently published Terry Pratchett novel, or it's the late 1990s/early 2000s and you've just come off a decade of reading Dragonlance, Mercedes Lackey, Anne McCaffrey, et al, etc.

As 1983 is well past and nobody starts their fantasy reading with those books anymore, it's now unacceptable to begin there. But at the time I started reading Discworld, I was in that latter camp, and not knowing any better, enjoyed myself without thinking too much about what was going on. I got The Light Fantastic next, and then went to the bookstore, wanting more of the wizard cycle. So I went for Interesting Times.

I'd basically gotten couple of beginner's swimming lessons and then went running off the high dive.

As a novel, it's not Pratchett's best. It's not his most clever, most insightful, or most heartbreaking. I reread it a while ago and there's parts of it that show he had a ways to go to really become himself. And in rereading it, I saw how he harnessed his anger and fury at the petty human injustices in the world, and the ways in which he knew it could be better. I remembered reading the scenes illustrating the sheer magnitude of the gulf in between the people leading the wars and the people the wars were being fought for, and thinking about the pointlessness of martyrdom when there's work to be done to make the world as it needed to be. Things that I'd never read before and shook something deep inside that I knew I had to pay attention to. Ideas that were important.

The world isn't perfect. Don't stop trying to make it better.

Tikkun olam as filtered through a silly fantasy series that suddenly wasn't quite so silly anymore.

So it's not The Color of Magic that I hold tenderly for my fond memories of it, though I do think of that one with genuine affection. It's Interesting Times, because though there were a couple before it, that was the first proper Discworld book I ever read. And that's why I love picked it for today.

lebateleur: A picture of the herb sweet woodruff (Default)

[personal profile] lebateleur 2019-01-06 03:30 am (UTC)(link)
I usually recommend that everyone start Discworld with The Color of Magic, so they can experience that progression as unfolds. The added bonus is that I get the vicarious thrill of watching those people go from "Yeah, it was a cute book" to "Oh my god, you were right, these books are Big Ideas in disguise and it is amazing."

Although, the other half of me just wants to send them directly to Night Watch to experience the genius first thing.


petra: Barbara Gordon smiling knowingly (Default)

[personal profile] petra 2019-01-06 04:46 am (UTC)(link)
Mid-90s, McCaffrey from the library, weird Pratchett thing my mom borrowed from somebody, holy crap they're making jokes about PERN WHAT I NEED IT ALL.

The first one I remember sinking in past the level of "That was clearly referencing a whole lot of stories I haven't read" was Reaper Man.
angrboda: Viking style dragon head finial against a blue sky (Default)

[personal profile] angrboda 2019-01-06 07:13 am (UTC)(link)
I started with Colour of Magic and I've always read them in the order they were released. To do otherwise would just be so strange to me, I couldn't even imagine it. Even though they're not directly connected, I can't understand how one could just skip around in them. My sense of order won't permit it. :) Now that I have read most of them at least once, now I can pick and choose only the witchy (my favourite character group) books for example, but not the first time.

Lots of people deeply dislike Rincewind. I can't say I really understand why. I kind of miss him sometimes. And the luggage. I really like that luggage!
thenewbuzwuzz: converse on tree above ground (Default)

[personal profile] thenewbuzwuzz 2019-01-06 08:43 am (UTC)(link)
Wow, thank you! Yet another reminder that I need to read more Discworld. <3 (I think I've read most of the books, but not that one.)
ruuger: (Discworld - giraffe)

[personal profile] ruuger 2019-01-06 09:33 am (UTC)(link)
I think Discworld is one of the few series where it really doesn't matter where you start reading.

I started with Wyrd Sisters in 1995, because it happened to be in the new arrivals shelf at my local library (it was the first DW book translated into Finnish), followed by Mort, Reaper Man and Hogfather, as they were translated into Finnish, and then moved to reading the books in English in whatever order I happend to get them into my hands. I caught up with the publishing order sometime in the early 00's, but I didn't do a completele in-order reread until 2012-2013.

That reread was very interesting because you could see the progress in writing but also how some of Pratchett's main themes really were present from supriringly early. And I don't think I probably would have appreciated it so much had I read them in the correct order right from the start.
ruuger: (Discworld - giraffe)

[personal profile] ruuger 2019-02-10 09:30 am (UTC)(link)
Yeah, I think the best book is different for everyone. Though my friend - who loves DW now - always reminds me how I tried to get her to like the series by loaning her Witches Abroad when in her opinion I should have given her Small Gods instead :D
mizface: (Default)

[personal profile] mizface 2019-01-06 02:16 pm (UTC)(link)
*sigh* someday I'll have time to read Discworld - it sounds right up my alley
dragonyphoenix: (buffy)

[personal profile] dragonyphoenix 2019-01-07 04:12 am (UTC)(link)
I started with Colour of Magic but it was around '83 and I also came in from the reading Pern route. Actually, I'm wondering if I didn't read Colour of Magic first as a comic book. I'm not certain I've even read the book; it might just have been the comics. Long time ago. ;-)